Carole Samaha and Billie Holiday: Two Routes Into Interpretation
A useful between these artists is not a claim that they shared a method, but a contrast in the kinds of preparation documented for each.
Alignment: Both facts point toward interpretation as something shaped by craft, not only by the material being performed. That is a reading of the evidence, not a claim about either artist’s private beliefs or full creative process.
Complement and possible tension: Study and musical borrowing can expand one another, but creators might differ over when a learned framework should guide a performance and when it should be adapted or set aside. The supplied evidence does not show that Samaha and Holiday faced this tension, worked together, or held opposing views.
No figure-to-figure score is supplied, so I would leave the numeric comparison open rather than borrow a score from another pairing.